A New Genre Slave Narratives
n Abolitionists - a potent weapon in first-hand accounts of slavery by blacks who escaped from bondage or managed to buy their freedom.
n White activists recommended the slave narratives as unaltered testimonies.
n In fact they frequently re-wrote passages 11511g68l and fabricated events to excite the reader's interest and sympathy.
n Frederick Douglass: his abolitionist publishers told him simply to "give us the facts," and they would "take care of the philosophy."
n The collaboration between well-intentioned white editors and fugitive slaves usually resulted in hybrid works: mixture of verisimilitude (first-person narrative, professions of objectivity, documentary evidence - letters, bills of sale, newspaper clippings) with characteristics of sentimental fiction (garish asides, shrill polemics, melodramatic incidents).
n a potent new genre (the slave narratives) in which blacks wrote themselves in the American consciousness. Whatever their degree of veracity, the slave narratives both fed and increased the public appetite for accurate information concerning life in the "real world."
SLAVE NARRATIVE
NOTES
"I Was Born": Slave Narratives, Their Status as Autobiography and as Literature
JAMES OLNEY
Ex-slaves cannot talk about imagination, as other autobiographers / memoirists (151)
They cannot afford shedding doubts on their account;
it is assumed to be a clear, unfailing record of events sharp and distinct that need only be transformed into descriptive language to become the sequential narrative of a life in slavery. (151)
Fr fear that in so doing he will appear, from the present, to be reshaping and so distorting and falsifying the past (151)
the slave narrative is most often a non-memorial description fitted to a pre-formed mold [a mold with regular depressions here and equally regular prominences there] virtually obligatory figures, scenes, turns of phrase, observances, and authentications that carry over from narrative to narrative and give to them as a group the species character that we designate by the phrase "slave narrative." (151)
Species character: an extremely mixed production typically including any or all of the following:
o an engraved portrait or photograph of the subject of the narrative
o authenticating testimonials, prefixed or postfixed
o poetic epigraphs, snatches of poetry in the text, poems appended
o illustrations before, in the middle of, or after the narrative itself
o interruptions of the narrative proper by way of declamatory addresses to the reader and passages that as to style might well come from an adventure story, a romance, or a novel of sentiment
o bewildering variety of documents: letters to and from the narrator, bills of sale, newspaper clippings, notices of slave auctions and of escaped slaves, certificates of marriage, of manumission, of birth and death, wills, extracts from legal codes [that appear everywhere in the text, incl. footnotes & appendices]
o sermons and anti-slavery speeches and essays tacked on at the end to demonstrate post-narrative activities of the narrator (151-2)
An imagined master outline:
An engraved portrait, signed by the narrator.
A title page that includes the claim, as an integral part of the title, "Written by Himself" (or some close variant: "Written from a statement of Facts Made by Himself"; or "Written by a Friend, as Related to Him by Brother Jones"; etc .
A handful of testimonials and/or one or more prefaces or introductions written either by a white abolitionist friend of the narrator ( William Lloyd Garrison, Wendell Phillips) or by a white amanuensis/ editor/author actually responsible for the text ( John Greenleaf Whittier, David Wilson, Louis Alexis Chamerovzow), in the course of which preface the reader is told that the narrative is a "plain, unvarnished tale" and that naught "has been set down in malice, nothing exaggerated, nothing drawn from the imagination"-indeed, the tale, it is claimed, understates the horrors of slavery.
A poetic epigraph, by preference from William Cowper. [
The actual narrative:
o first sentence beginning, "I was born . . . ," then specifying a place but not a date of birth sketchy account of parentage, often involving a white father
o description of a cruel master, mistress, or overseer, details of first observed whipping and numerous subsequent whippings, with women very frequently the victims
o account of one extraordinarily strong, hardworking slave often "pure African"-who, because there is no reason for it, refuses to be whipped
o record of the barriers raised against slave literacy and the overwhelming difficulties encountered in learning to read and write
o description of a "Christian" slaveholder (often of one such dying in terror) and the accompanying claim that "Christian" slave-holders are invariably worse than those professing no religion
o description of the amounts and kinds of food and clothing given to slaves, the work required of them, the pattern of a day, a week, a year
o account of a slave auction, of families being separated and destroyed, of distraught mothers clinging to their children as they are torn from them, of slave coffles being driven South
o description of patrols, of failed attempt(s) to escape, of pursuit by men and dogs
o description
of successful attempt(s) to escape, lying by during the day, travelling by
night guided by the North Star, reception in a
o taking of a new last name (frequently one suggested by a white abolitionist) to accord with new social identity as a free man, but retention of first name as a mark of continuity of individual identity .
An appendix or appendices composed of documentary material: bills of sale, details of purchase from slavery, newspaper items-, further reflections on slavery, sermons, anti-slavery speeches, poems, appeals to the reader for funds and moral support in the battle against slavery. (152)
Example: Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, An American Slave, Written by Himself
what is being recounted in the narratives is nearly always the realities of the institution of slavery, almost never the intellectual, emotional, moral growth of the narrator [Douglass is an exception] (..) The lives in the narratives are never, or almost never, there for themselves and for their own intrinsic, unique interest but nearly always in their capacity as illustrations of what slavery is really like. Thus in one sense the narrative lives of the ex-slaves were as much possessed and used by the abolitionists as their actual lives had been by slaveholders (154).
o John Brown 's story is titled Slave Life in Georgia and only subtitled " A Narrative of the Life, Sufferings, and Escape of John Brown, A Fugitive Slave,"
o Charles
Ball's story is called Slavery in the United States, with the somewhat extended subtitle
"A Narrative of the Life and Adventures of Charles Ball, A Black Man, who lived forty years in
o The central focus of these two, as of nearly all the narratives, is slavery, an institution and an external reality, rather than a particular and individual life as it is known internally and subjectively. (154)
"I was born" - the need to attest to his/her existence
as the primary reason, incl. the photos;
behind every slave narrative that is in any way characteristic or representative there is the one same persistent and dominant motivation, which is determined by the interplay of narrator, sponsors, and audience and which itself determines the narrative in theme, content, and form.
o The theme is the reality of slavery and the necessity of abolishing it
o the content is a series of events and descriptions that will make the reader see and feel the realities of slavery
o the form is a chronological, episodic narrative beginning with an assertion of existence and surrounded by various testimonial evidences for that assertion (156)
subthemes of literacy, identity, and freedom (156)
David Wilson, editor (+ intrudions in the text; fragments rewritten) of Narrative of Henry Box Brown; intrusions modeled on the sentimental novel (H.B. Stowe - on the dedication page)
John Brown's narrative: Louis Alexis Chamerovzow, the "Editor" (actually author) of Slave Life in Georgia
Sarah Bradford -- Scenes in the Life of Harriet Tubman
William Lloyd Garrison - reference to Othello (whereas F. Douglass identifies himself with Hamlet): The Moor, Shakespeare's or Garrison's, was noble, certainly, but he was also a creature of unreliable character and irrational passion-such, at least, seems to have been the logic of the abolitionists' attitude toward their ex-slave speakers and narrators-and it was just as well for the white sponsor to keep him, if possible, on a pretty short leash. (166)
the
Afro-American literary tradition takes its start, in theme certainly but also
often in content and form, from the slave narratives (e.g. R. Wright's Black Boy) (168)
1919 - return of highly decorated Black 369th
Infantry, which marched from the docks, down Broadway, and through
the "Red Summer" of 1919 - approx. 25 race riots in all sections of the country
poverty, particularly in the South
Emergence of a black middle class > increased education and job opportunities following the Civil War (Du Bois, for instance, was a Harvard graduate)
New
political agenda advocating racial equality - Du Bois and N.A.A.C.P. (the
National Association for the Advancement of Colored People, 1909) as opposed to
Booker T. Washington's viewpoint with respect to the role & position of the
African Americans in the
Jazz and blues /the poetry of Paul Laurence Dunbar and fiction of Charles W. Chestnutt - national recognition; + Claude MacKay & James Weldon Johnson (The Autobigraphy of an [Ex-] Colored Man)
March
1924 - the National Urban League - dinner meant to celebrate the new black
literary talents & to introduce them to the white audience; special issue
of the Survey Graphic dedicated to
1926 -
the publication of Carl Van Vechten's Nigger
Heaven [white novelist] -
Savages! Savages at heart! And she
had lost or forfeited her birthright, this primitive birthright which was so
valuable and important an asset, a birthright that all the civilized races were
struggling to get back to-this fact explained the art of a Picasso or a
Stravinsky. To be sure, she, too, felt this African beat--it completely aroused
her emotionally--but she was conscious of feeling it. This love of drums, of
exciting rhythms, this naive delight in glowing colour--the colour that exists
only in cloudless, tropical climes--this warm, sexual emotion, all these were
hers only through a mental understanding. With Olive these qualities were
instinctive. . . . Why, Mary asked herself, is this denied me? (qtd. in
Autumn 1926 - a group of young black writers produced Fire!
James Weldon Johnson's description of reactions
to
It is known in Europe and the Orient,
and it is talked about by natives in the interior of
The exotic image comes from Blacks themselves and from white sympathizers:
Shuffle Along (1921) - popular musical, written and directed by four Blacks-Flournoy Miller, Eubie Blake, Noble Sissle, and Aubrey Lyles
Put and Take (1921) - Irving C. Miller, who also produced Liza (1923)
chorus girls such as Florence Mills and Josephine Baker
Primitivism & dancing - Langston Hughes & Z.N. Hurston's How It Feels to Be Colored Me
Sherwood Anderson - Dark Laughter (1925) conjures the image of a joyful, untroubled people who, themselves freed from the need to read Freud, laugh gently at frustrated whites, who repress their own sexual desires
Home to Harlem (1928) Claude McKay, a Black West Indian, drowned social protest in his flood of night life-prostitutes, sweetmen, jazz, fights-as he told the story of a Black deserter from the armed services who searches through Harlem for the lost prostitute whom he loves.
Rudolph Fisher in The Walls of Jericho (1928) and Wallace Thurman in The Blacker the Berry (1929 seemed almost compelled to include irrelevant night club scenes as though they had become clichés of Black life.
W.E.B. DuBois, with great alarm, used the pages of The Crisis to question whether writers and publishers shared his fear that Black writers were being encouraged to create derogatory pictures of Blacks.
BACKGROUND:
Alan Locke: "The New Negro"
Zora Neale Hurston - How It Feels to Be Colored Me
F.S. Fitzgerald - "Echoes of the Jazz Age"
The Great Depression NAACP & the Urban League focused on economic and social matters
The 1935
Broer , Lawrence R. and John D. Walther
(eds.). Dancing Fools and Weary Blues:
The Great Escape of the Twenties.
The
One Facet of an Untwisted Kaleidoscope
In such ways as these, Black writers of the Renaissance explored serious issues involving Black people but not deriving primarily from the racial ancestry or from their relationship with whites.
+ a search for and affirmation of ancestral heritage, a feeling of alienation from the white Euro-American world; a presentation of and protest against oppression; and even militant defiance of oppression.
identity through identification with an ancestral past
Jean Toomer - Cane, "Natalie Mann"
Countée Cullen -"Heritage"
Langston Hughes - "The Negro Speaks of Rivers"
The identification is not by all means problematic - There Is Confusion Jessie Fauset suggested the problems sometimes posed by the quest for European ancestry. Moreover, Blacks who wished to affirm a Black heritage were forced to identify with a continent rather than with a particular tribe or nation; L. Hughes - "Afro-American Fragment"
sense of alienation = impossibility to achieve a sense of belonging - difficulty in relating oneself at a personal level to the Black heritage + exclusion & marginalization from the European heritage:
McKay's "Outcast" and "The White House"
protests against oppression.
Walter White's novel The Fire in the Flint (1924)
Claude McKay's "The Lynching."
Toomer's "Blood-Burning Moon" and "Kabnis" (Cane).
Sometimes indirectly by showing how it causes Blacks to turn against themselves
Comedy : American Style (1933) Fauset gently censured a Negro mother who values her children according to the degree of their approximation to Caucasian appearance.
Walter White's Flight (1928) and Nella Larsen's Passing (1929) show the dilemmas of heroines who, repressed by the conditions of life as Blacks, attempt to improve their lot by passing for white.
Jean Toomer repeatedly stressed the necessity for middle-class Negroes to liberate themselves from conscious imitation of the restrictive morality of Anglo Saxons - "Natalie Mann."
militant reaction often was expressed as self-defense (Claude McKay's "If We Must Die") / prayers for destruction (McKay's "Enslaved")
Most often - a proud hostility towards whites - Flight.
VARIETY OF EXPRESSION (black vernacular/ African-American experience + modernist experimentation)
Bernard W. Bell - The Afro-American Novel and Its Tradition.
POETIC REALISM AND HISTORICAL ROMANCE
Poetic realism - Jean Toomer's Cane (psychological approach to the modern black artist; experimental in form; Freudian themes - preoccupied with the theme of the repressed self); "represents a synthesis of the concerns of writers of the Lost Generation and the Harlem Renaissance, and his work embodies the tensions of modern science and folk tradition, of psychoanalytic technique and Afro-American music, of mysticism and Afro-American spirituality" (96)
Historical romance - Arna Bontemps's Black Thunder (retelling of a heroic legend in a traditional form)
Jean Toomer
"I am not a romanticist, I am not a classicist or a realist, in the usual sense of these terms. I am an essentialist. Or, to put it in other words, I am a spiritualizer, a poetic realist." (Toomer, early draft of his autobiography).
transcendency of the soul and the attainment of spiritual truth through intuition.
he tried "to lift facts, things, happenings to the planes of rhythm, feeling, and significance. . . . to clothe and give body to potentialities." (Toomer qtd. in Bell 97)
Cane
Part 1 - focus on the Southern past and the libido /the rural thesis
Part 2 - emphasis on the centers of commerce and the superego/the urban antithesis
Part 3 - a synthesis of the earlier sections with Kabnis representing the black writer who finds it difficult to resolve the tension between the two.
99
With Negroes also the trend was towards the small town and then towards the city--and industry and commerce and machines. The folk spirit was walking in to die on the modern desert. That spirit was so beautiful. Its death was so tragic. Just this seemed to sum up life for me. And this was the feeling I put into Cane. (404)
I am at once no one of the races and I am all of them. I belong to no When I come up to
confronts me.... For it is jazzed,
strident, modern.
is the song of crude new life. Of a new people. Negro? Only in the
boldness of expression. In its healthy freedom. American.
Arna Bontemps (1902-73)
Court records, newspapers, journals, and letters - documentary sources of narrative authority
omniscient narrator + experiment with multiple points of view and interior monologue (third-person objective with first-and third-person subjective techniques). (101 -104)
GENTEEL REALISM: ASSIMILATIONISM, NATIONALISM, OR BICULTURALISM
Jessie Redmon Fauset (1882-1961)
stresses the genteel tradition and everyday rituals of the urban black elite
rather sentimental depiction of this class
moral of her novels: the
respectable, genteel black American "is not so vastly different from any
other American, just distinctive." (qtd. in
Nella Larsen (1893-1963)
FOLK ROMANCE: PASTORALISM, PRIMITIVISM, AND ANCESTRALISM
Savages! Savages at heart! And
she had lost or forfeited her birthright, this primitive birthright which was
so valuable and important an asset, a birthright that all the civilized races
were struggling to get back to-this fact explained the art of a Picasso or a
Stravinsky. To be sure, she, too, felt this African beat--it completely aroused
her emotionally--but she was conscious of feeling it. This love of drums, of
exciting rhythms, this naive delight in glowing colour--the colour that exists
only in cloudless, tropical climes--this warm, sexual emotion, all these were
hers only through a mental understanding. With Olive these qualities were
instinctive. . . . Why, Mary asked herself, is this denied me? (qtd. in
the international scope of the concept of ancestralism is apparent in the Négritude movement of Caribbean and Francophone West African writers; coined in 1939 by Aimé Césaire in "Journal of a Return to My Native Country," a long narrative poem, and popularized in 1948 by Léopold Senghor in New Anthology of Black and Malagasian Poetry.
Festus Claudius Mc Kay (1899-1948)
transcended the primitivism of Van Vechten by drawing on his authentic racial past (Jamaica Ashanti) and intellectual independence
poetry, a collection of short stories, Gingertown ( 1932), and three novels, Home to Harlem ( 1928), Banjo ( 1929), and Banana Bottom ( 1933)
exploits the literary
primitivism of his white peers. Relying more heavily on black idiom, slang, sex, animal imagery,
gratuitous violence, and a noble-savage motif than its apparent model, "Home
to Harlem," as a contemporary reviewer wrote, "is Nigger
Heaven in a larger and more violent dose." (qtd. in
By focusing on the urban black worker and penetrating the surface vitality of his struggle to survive, Home to Harlem moves beyond the primitivism of Nigger Heaven
Banjo is as much a rejection of the black bourgeoisie and white civilization as it is a celebration of black folk values and cultural pluralism
The rural Jamaican setting, village characters, colorful dialogue, and tranquil mood of Banana Bottom make it the most conventional and successful of McKay's pastoral romances
Zora Neale Hurston (1891-1960)
folk romances are set in the
emphasize the pastoral aspects of rural black life with which the author was familiar
three romances, Jonah's Gourd Vine ( 1934), Their Eyes Were Watching God ( 1937), and Moses: Man of the Mountain ( 1939); and her novel, Seraph on the Suwanee (focus on whites; 1948).
metaphorical style; folksy language.
FOLK REALISM: RELIGION, MUSIC, HUMOR, AND LANGUAGE
James Langston Hughes (1902-67)
Not Without Laughter is the story of a
black boy growing up in Stanton, a small
Tambourines to Glory is a comic novel about the attitude of simple black urban folk toward religion (131-33)
"The Negro Artist and the Racial Mountain"
We younger Negro artists who create now intend to express our individual dark-skinned selves without fear or shame. If white people are please we are glad. If they are not, it doesn't matter. We know we are beautiful. And ugly, too. (.) If colored people are pleased, we are glad. If they are not, their displeasure doesn't matter either. We build our temples for tomorrow, strong as we know how, and we stand on top of the mountain, free within ourselves. Encarta Encyclopedia 2003
Countee Porter Cullen (1903-46)
The most highly educated and technically proficient traditional lyricist of the Harlem Renaissance (133)
In technique his verse is strongly influenced by Keats and Shelley, and in theme, by racial ambivalence that vacillates between African ancestralism and Western classicism (134)
A single novel--One Way to Heaven -- gullibility and superstition of unsophisticated lower-class urban blacks + sardonic treatment of the pretentious customs of the black bourgeoisie (134)
SATIRIC REALISM: THE VICES AND FOLLIES OF THE FOLK AND BLACK BOURGEOISIE
Rudolph Fisher (1897-1934)
George Samuel Schuyler (1895-1977)
Wallace Thurman (1902-34)
Mihai Mindra's Course Notes on African American academic writing (to be included)
Neo-slave narrative: contemporary novels that assume the form, adopt the conventions, and take on the first-person voice of the the antebellum slave narrative (3)
Ishmael Reed Flight to
Sherley Anne Williams Dessa Rose ( 1986)
Charles Johnson Oxherding Tale ( 1982) and Middle Passage (1990)
o its origins in the social, intellectual, and racial formations of the sixties
o its cultural politics as these texts intervene in debates over the significance of race
o its literary politics as these texts make statements on engagements between texts and between mainstream and minority traditions (3)
Black Power movement + the rise of the New Left changes at social & cultural level; incl. the understanding of history (New Left historians: analyzing history from the bottom up; importance attached to testimonies) (4)
William Styron - The Confessions of Nat Turner (+Daniel Panger in Ol' Prophet Nat); challenged by the Black Power movement intellectuals
Factors which generated the new genre:
historiographical representation of slavery
meaning of Black Power
significance of Styron's Confessions. (5)
Margaret Walker historical novel Jubilee ( 1966)
Ernest Gaines' novel The Autobiography of Miss Jane Pittman (1971)
|